Authenticated Beanie Babies Price Guide

During the peak of Ty Beanie Babies popularity, many counterfeit versions poured onto the marketplace like on sites like eBay. Savvy Beanie collectors during that time turned their passion for the collectibles into a business and began authenticating Beanie Babies.

Authenticated Beanie Babies come in a sealed plastic case. The cost to authenticate is generally $15+ for the top level service. The two most active Beanie Babies authenticators still going are True Blue Beans and Peggy Gallagher. Together they have authenticated tens of thousands of Beanie Babies.

Some authenticated Ty Beanie Babies can sell for hundreds of dollars.

Click on the links below to see what the authenticated version sells for.

Sales prices are from online sites like eBay, Amazon, and the official Beanie Babies Facebook For Sale Group.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Tgries5 - December 22, 2016

I have a March 23, 1998 praying Hope Bear that I would like to sell. I would like to know if someone would actually give me 3,000. It would be nice so I can my my baby’s grave marker.

Reply
    Lea Kanstrup - May 15, 2020

    Binksy – $7 Biscuit – $ Bits – $6 Bixby – $3 Blackie – See Guide BLARN-e – $10 Blessed – $8 Bliss – $15 Blissful – $10 Blitz – $6 Blizzard – $4 Bloom – $4 Bloom FTD – $30 Bloomfield – $5 Blue Bear – $5 Blue Dog – $5 Blue Beanie Shoes – $6 Bluebonnet – $4 Bo – $4 Bodkin Boblin – $5 Bones – See Guide Boneses – $6 Bongo – $5 Bonnet – $9 Bonsai – $5 Bonzer – $3 Boo Who? – $8 Books – $5 Boomer – $5 Booties – $5 Boots – $5 Boston – $5 Bounder – $15 Bounds – $12 Boston Red Sox – $5 Breadcrumbs – $3 Bride – $5 Brigitte – $3 Britannia – $6 British Columbia – $5 Brittany – $5 Brobee – $5 Bronty – See Guide Brownie – See Guide Bruno – $3 Brutus – $10 Bubbles – $5 Bubbly – $2 Buck – $15 Buckingham – $10 Bucky (d Generation) $15 Bucky (h Generation) $3 Buff – $5 Bugs Bunny – $30 Bumble (d Generation) $?35 Bumble (h Generation) $2?5 Bunga – $5

    Reply
joytotheworld57 - July 18, 2017

i have a giving bear and a m&ms. what are they worth?

Reply
Max - August 14, 2017

I have a Valentino 1993 with 9 errors. Anyone interested?

Reply
    Kaytee - February 5, 2020

    lol nope

    Reply
carrie - August 23, 2017

Is there a price guide for beanie buddies?

Reply
    Judy Seckel - October 1, 2019

    Well its 2019 and I still cant find a price guide on beanie babies worth? If anyone know of one please email gmaseckel@gmail.com

    Reply
Kari - September 17, 2017

I have a version 1 millennium bear with all errors. What are these going for?

Reply
Amanda M Hruska - October 14, 2017

I have a mint condition Erin bear among many other discontinued beanie babies. I am looking to sell them BC I don’t have the room to store them anymore

Reply
Amanda M Hruska - October 14, 2017

Can give pictures if needed

Reply
anthony - November 6, 2018

is everyone confused about the price of 0f the 1997 and 1998 editions. I see them on ebay some selling for lot less than $100 and other identical ones in mint condition going for thousands.. can condition make that much difference or people just don’t know if they have a valuable item. when I was 12 in 1997 I pre ordered princess diana. I would assume I got one of the first editions but prices on ebay are confusing. mine was handmade in china. if I did not get the most valuable item then what was I given??

Reply
cheryl hulet - November 27, 2018

T I HAVE A SPANGLE BEAR,–CHILLY BEAR—THE END BEAR, HOW MUCH ARE THEY WORTH?

Reply
Branden - December 24, 2018

Yes I have a yellow chicken name bonnie no birthdate on ear tag and bottom tag is brown says 1993 the chicken is wearing a blue bonnet I cant seem to fund it any were

Reply
Jennifer - December 30, 2018

I have a few and I would like to know if worth anything could someone please help

Reply
Scott - January 1, 2019

How do you tell which Americana beanie is worth more than the others?

Reply
    Beanie Price Guide - January 15, 2019

    They are probably all the same

    Reply
KIM - January 1, 2019

How much is a Chocolate the moose without a hang tag worth?, the tush tag is a 6th generation and it is p.e.

Reply
    Beanie Price Guide - January 15, 2019

    .50 Cents

    Reply
Sandra Kregelka - January 13, 2019

I have a Claude the crab from 1996 with tag on Is it worth what ive read on Etsy

Reply
    Beanie Price Guide - January 15, 2019

    Almost nothing.

    Reply
Denese - January 18, 2019

I have a Color Me Beanie (never out of the box) DOB December 11 2001. I have never seen one anywhere. Can anyone tell me anything about this one

Reply
Hannah Johnson - January 29, 2019

We recently acquired a Whisper fawn. She is in great condition! With the tag errors. Someone said she was worth up to 3000. I feel that is a crazy amount! My husband would love to sell her but I really think if there is not significant value I’d like to put her in our Son’s nursery! Can you help us?

Reply
    Emma - February 12, 2019

    I have the same one and while doing some research I found that she is only worth around $10. I chose not to sell her yet and wait until her price goes up. I recommend you do the same.

    Reply
Wendy Schmidt - April 17, 2019

Three items: Patti with the ty star tag. Princess with the ty star tag. Halo with the ty star tag. I have all three that are on your list. Also, I’ve been hearing something about the teenie beanie bears with the different nationality like Canada and Brit and Amer. Are any of these worth selling? And where does one sell?

Reply
E. Marie McArtor - May 9, 2019

I have a CubbaLove bear – how much is it worth?

Reply
Kim - May 28, 2019

I have a box of beanie babies in great condition, I just need to know the value of them so I can sell them.

Reply
Ricardo Dominguez - June 5, 2019

My Beanie Baby is Piccadilly 1993, bear in a clown suit new condition in a plastic case with heart on lid and bottom of case and a card board insert with trees and the word Ringo in side also has a brown tag is it the golden Beanie Baby should i quit my job and get started on the bucket list? So what’s the deal with my Baby?

Reply
Becky Brown - July 1, 2019

I have 9 beanie bears that are Rangers baseball team in August 1998. They are in excellent condition with tags still on them. Are they worth anything ?

Reply
Gaye Martin - July 2, 2019

I would like to know how I can get my BB’s authenticated
Thank you

Reply
Edward Newman - July 21, 2019

Fraidy Born Oct. 13,2000

Reply
Chris - July 21, 2019

Looking for price on “snort” the red bull.

Reply
    Kim - December 30, 2019

    I have one looking to sell

    Reply
STEVEN STOLARSKI - July 27, 2019

HAVE A 1993 PATTI BEANIE BABY UNOPENED. HAS A 1 ON PACKAGE. WAS GIVEN TO ME ALMOST 21 YRS AGO ON MY 50TH BIRTHDAY.ANYONE KNOW THE VALUE .

Reply
Mike - August 5, 2019

I have we smoochey and legs. I’m not sure if they are first generation. I can do text photos.

Reply
Jlee - September 14, 2019

I have a 1st gen. Spooky the ghost that’s retired. And it’s never been played with. The D.O.B IS 10-31-95 plz if anyone know’s anything about it could you let me know something about what it’s worth. Thank you.

Reply
Anthony Dubois - November 18, 2019

I have a lot of I think valuable Bennie babies and I have no money to pay for an appraiser does anybody know how I could get somebody to help me pay for one I would appreciate the help and when I sell my thing I would pay them back

Reply
Barbara - December 11, 2019

Good Morning to All,
I am helping my father go thru his deceased wife’s Beanie baby collection. She passed away over 10 years ago and the babies are just sitting in a storage cabinet. We have over 100 and some I have heard are collectible items.
My question is how can I get the word out to sell some of these items? Is this the forum to do so?
Thank you

Reply
Nancy - December 25, 2019

I have an error peace bear in awesome condition

Reply
Tosha - December 25, 2019

I have several several beanie babies. 1st,2ed and 3ed generations. Some with errors and some without. How in the heck do I find out what each one is worth? Please email me if you can help with a link or something.
toshawilliams166@gmail.com

Reply
Jeff - January 22, 2020

I have a pink hippity with 2 I’s in original with the tag protector and is in really good shape. What’s that worth?

Reply
Heather - February 7, 2020

Came across rainbow the iguana. Found in plastic ziplock sandwich bag Bluish green with tag protector. Gold star. Dob 10/14/96. Mint condition

Reply
Denise Whipp - February 20, 2020

I have a collection of beanie babies from the 1990’s that i believe to be 1st generation including Princess Diana And Erin also Peace Bear and many many others……..please contact me if interested! They are all in mint condition with perfect tags……

Reply
Jacob - March 7, 2020

I have a 1996 Nuts. Style 4114 in amazing shape. Could someone know the answer.? Or can email me at jacobhovatter8@gmail.com

Reply
Tina Upchurch - March 10, 2020

I have Diana Princess bear. And would like to sell, have authincated

Reply
Melissa - March 12, 2020

My friend has a millenium bear that is spelled wm instead of um we can not find a price for that

Reply
Paul DArcangelo - March 16, 2020

is there a price guide for beanie babies

Reply
Blondie - March 23, 2020

I have two beanie babies with special ribbons tied around there necks with the names of plays on them from Pantages Theater in Toronto canada! Are the valuable?

Reply
Jessica - June 9, 2020

I have Rainbow (1999). Does anyone know what the value is???

Reply
Emily - June 23, 2020

I have a TY Beanie Babies Official Club Clubby IV with a rainbow button. Brand new condition but no case. Is he worth anything?

Reply
    Beanie Price Guide - August 4, 2020

    No

    Reply
Sam - July 2, 2020

Does ANYONE know how much a 1993 Ty Justin Monkey Style 6044 goes for?
Collectable tag.

I can’t find it ANYWHERE

Reply
Richard Holland - July 11, 2020

I have about 20 different babies that i have been looking on Ebay to price. How can i get all of them accurately valued / priced?

Reply
    Beanie Price Guide - August 4, 2020

    Go to Love My Beanies

    Reply
Adam - July 27, 2020

I have bubbles make offer let it go cheap 218-259-2939

Reply
    james casarez - November 8, 2020

    How much for bubbles?

    Reply
joe nuts - August 28, 2020

full mint set of 1998 McDonalds promotional beanie babies for like 20 bucks
http://ebay.us/g9D4RB?cmpnId=5338273189

Reply
Elaine Turner - November 14, 2020

I have a Valentina beanie. On the bottom tag it says it is a Millennium.
The tag on the ear says Valentina birth February 14,1998. How much would
it be worth with the incorrect bottom tag.

Reply
Haven McBride - December 5, 2020

I have a 1998 Snort beanie buddy. I am having a hard time finding if beanie buddies are worth any money? Any thoughts?

Reply
Leave a Reply: